top of page
pporwall

Comparing Costs: Homemade Dog Food vs. Farmer's Dog Subscription - What's the Most Cost-Effective Choice for Your Pooch?

When it comes to feeding our beloved canine companions, many dog owners often face the dilemma between commercial dog food subscriptions and preparing homemade meals. With the rise of subscription services like Farmer's Dog, which offers fresh, vet-formulated dog food delivered to your door, the options have become more enticing. Many pet parents are curious about the costs and benefits of homemade dog food. This blog post reviews the expenses associated with both options, helping you determine the most cost-effective choice for your dog.


Understanding the Farmer's Dog Subscription


Farmer's Dog provides a meal subscription service that promises fresh, human-grade dog food tailored by veterinarians. Their plans let you select recipes customized for your dog’s specific dietary needs. Deliveries are made directly to your home, catering to busy pet owners seeking convenience without sacrificing quality.


Cost of Farmer's Dog Subscription


On average, a Farmer's Dog subscription ranges from about $3 to $6 per day, depending on your dog's size and dietary preferences. This translates to a weekly expenditure between $21 and $42.


For example, a medium-sized dog might cost around $4 daily. This totals approximately $28 weekly. For pet owners prioritizing convenience, this could be a reasonable investment in their furry friend’s well-being.


Fresh dog meals from Farmer's Dog
Freshly prepared meals from Farmer's Dog, delivered to your door.

Breaking Down Homemade Dog Food Costs


Turning to homemade dog food can provide peace of mind regarding the quality and freshness of your dog's meals. But how much will a week’s worth of homemade meals actually cost?


Key Ingredients and Their Prices


To create high-quality homemade dog food, consider incorporating various ingredients, including:


  • Lean meats: (e.g., chicken, beef)

  • Vegetables: (e.g., carrots, peas, sweet potatoes)

  • Grains: (e.g., rice, oats)


The average prices for these ingredients might look like this:


  • Lean Meats: Approximately $4 to $10 per pound.

  • Vegetables: About $1 to $3 per pound.

  • Grains: Roughly $1 to $2 per pound.


Calculating the Total Costs for a Week


Let’s consider a straightforward recipe for a week that includes:


  • 2 pounds of chicken: $8 (at $4 per pound)

  • 1 pound of carrots: $2

  • 1 pound of peas: $2

  • 2 pounds of rice: $2


This combination brings the total cost for preparing meals for one medium-sized dog to around $14 for the entire week.


Pros and Cons of Each Feeding Method


Homemade Dog Food - Pros and Cons


Pros:


  1. Customization: Tailoring meals to meet your dog's specific needs and preferences is possible.

  2. Quality Control: You have full insight into the ingredients, helping to eliminate harmful additives or fillers often found in commercial dog foods.


Cons:


  1. Time-Consuming: Regular meal preparation requires a commitment of time and effort that may challenge busy owners.

  2. Nutritional Balance: Achieving a balanced diet can be tricky and may require detailed research to ensure all nutritional needs are met.


Farmer's Dog Subscription - Pros and Cons


Pros:


  1. Convenience: Meals come ready to serve, significantly reducing preparation time.

  2. Nutritionally Balanced: Meals are curated by veterinarians to provide the necessary nutrients for your dog's health.


Cons:


  1. Cost: Weekly expenses can accumulate quickly, especially for larger dogs who may need more food.

  2. Less Control Over Ingredients: Some ingredients may not align with your personal preferences or beliefs about dog nutrition.


What’s Cheaper: Subscription Dog Food or Homemade Dog Food?


When comparing costs, homemade dog food generally proves to be more economical. Based on prior calculations, a week of homemade meals costs about $14, while a subscription such as the Farmer's Dog could total approximately $28 for the same period.


Potential Long-Term Savings


Choosing homemade dog food not only offers short-term savings but can also lead to long-lasting benefits. By preparing meals in bulk and making strategic purchases of ingredients, you can lower your cost per meal. Although the initial investment in time and research may be substantial, many dog owners value knowing exactly what they are feeding their pets.


Homemade dog food preparation
Homemade dog food preparation with fresh ingredients for your pet.

Final Thoughts on Feeding Your Dog


Selecting the right diet for your dog requires considering factors like cost, convenience, and nutritional value.


Based on a cost analysis, it appears that homemade dog food can be the cheaper option when compared to a Farmer's Dog subscription, especially for those who have the time and effort to prepare meals. However, it is essential to assess what best suits your lifestyle and aligns with your dog’s health needs.


Ultimately, whether opting for homemade meals or a subscription service like Farmer's Dog or other subscriptions, the most important aspect is ensuring that your furry friend receives a balanced and healthy diet tailored to their specific requirements.

Comments


bottom of page